Archive for the ‘authenticity’ Category

Are you looking for love in all the wrong places?

Monday, September 22nd, 2008

I wish people didn’t call it “new media” anymore.

It’s just media.

But unlike television, radio and print, this media is created by you, me, your co-workers—maybe even your mom.

It’s a conversation that brings you closer to the customer than ever before at a time when recent research has shown that 86% of consumers don’t believe brands, but 78% of consumers believe what their peers say about brands.

But check out this comparison of average media usage versus average media spend from Chris Schaumann’s excellent Digital Branding presentation.

Click to view Chris Schaumann's Digital Branding presentation

The disconnect is immediately evident: If you aren’t marketing online, you’re looking for love in all the wrong places.

So, what about the customers you already have?

The Break Up is an award-winning viral video from Microsoft that shows the painful disconnect between what today’s consumer wants, and how advertisers are (or aren’t) responding:

So, what are you doing to engage your customer and prospects?

Comment below to share.

Subscribe to this feed.

. . .

Inspiration for this post came, albeit circuitously, from the following people: Justin Marshall > Ryan Turner > Geert Desager > Chris Schaumann

Can’t buy me love: Paid conversation seeding

Monday, July 14th, 2008

Authenticity is the marketing buzzword du jour, and for good reason: There’s a huge trust gap between marketers and consumers and the more “real” you can be, the better.

So, is the following Responsible Marketing?

Top Quality & Affordable Forum Population
Paid forum posting is about providing your forum, blog or community a jumpstart, by seeding your site with active conversation & enthusiastic members. From visitors to Google, your site will start getting the notice it deserves!

The notice it deserves? Everyone has to start somewhere, but paying strangers to pretend they are interested in your content is downright sad.

Here’s their pricing:

You can’t buy love

If your blog or forum is a ghost town, does your content need a little help? If it’s worthy, don’t sink to buying a temporary audience.

Instead, share it with the people you know and seek out individuals and groups that might be interested in what you have to say.

If you have quality content, an audience will follow. Like any relationship, first you have to establish trust. And that’s pretty tough to pull off if your conversations are phony.

What do you think about paid conversation seeding?

Unethical or just “faking it until you make it?”

Comment below to weigh in.

Responsible Marketing is marketing without an *

Thursday, July 3rd, 2008

We don’t trust anyone anymore. It seems the great politicians, celebrities, corporate titans and athletes have all let us down one way or another.

And while part of our psyche seems to revel in watching the demise of greatness, there’s also a part of us that hurts a little.

Where have all the good ones gone?

Yesterday, Barry Bonds’ controversial 756th home run ball was delivered to the Baseball Hall of Fame by Mark Ecko, the fashion designer that acquired the ball in an auction for $752,467. Ecko conducted an online poll to determine what to do with the ball, and the winning choice was to carve an asterisk into the ball.

For those that aren’t aware of the significance of the asterisk, most baseball fans believe the record is dirty due to Bonds alleged steroid use and it shouldn’t count. If Bonds did indeed use steroids, he cheated. And if that’s the case, since he said he didn’t use steroids while under oath, he’ll be a liar and may be found guilty of perjury.

What does all this have to do with Responsible Marketing?

Your marketing results should never come with an asterisk. Here are are few examples to illustrate what I mean:

  • If you use fear, deception or any form of trickery to get people to buy your product, your results come with an *.
  • If you cheat, by using data you don’t have permission to use, even if you don’t get caught, your results come with an *.
  • If you lie, by greenwashing or puffery to make your product, service or company something it’s not, your results come with an *.
  • If your marketing is culturally insensitive and hurts more people than it helps, your results come with an *.
  • If your testimonials aren’t real, your results come with an *.
  • This is obviously just the tip of the iceberg.

    I’d like to know what other marketing activities you believe are worthy of an *.

    Comment below to weigh in.

    OMFG: Responsible or not?

    Tuesday, June 24th, 2008

    For the uninitiated:

    OMG = “Oh my God.”
    OMFG = The same, plus a strategically placed F-bomb.

    First time I saw these ads, I wanted to write about it here, but I couldn’t seem to find the CW’s justification for taking “OMG,”—a phrase that already puts some people on edge—and plusing it with the “F” for extra shock appeal.

    Personally, I grew up in a household where “Oh my gosh” would raise eyebrows because it was so close to “Oh my God,” which takes the Lord’s name in vain. Readers of this blog know I’m no Saint: I used the word “sh**” in a post just last week — and have posted some risque videos. But the fact is, I’m hardwired by my upbringing.

    Anyway, I assumed it was to shock the viewer into paying attention—to break through the clutter by slipping something naughty past the FCC. I also assumed it was a calculated move to gain secondary attention from the media—that the CW knew full well this would create the kind of controversy that gets people talking.

    As it turns out, I was 2/3 right.

    Last week’s Promax/BDA CMO Summit featured a panel that included the CW’s CMO Rick Haskin. He was asked point blank about the ads, and agreed they were meant to break through and was pleased with the additional attention the controversy created.

    Knowing only this much, you might want to call the CW and their tactic irresponsible.

    But wait, there’s more.

    Haskin claims that the CW really listened to their viewers, and discovered that the OMFG phrase was one of the phrases most commonly used to describe the show—that their messages would start, “OMFG…”

    Listening to your customers and speaking to them in their own voice makes the conversation more authentic and is indeed Responsible Marketing.

    I’m just not sure if this is brilliant marketing—or brilliant spin-doctoring.

    But what do you think? Was the CW responsible or not?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    . . .

    Source: Interview on 3 Minute Ad Age.

    History’s worst viral campaign, or best?

    Friday, June 13th, 2008

    Above are two of four videos that were uploaded to YouTube two weeks ago proving that the radiation from cell phones is strong enough to actually pop corn.

    Or not.

    As it turns out, it’s a hoax—a viral marketing ploy by Cardo Systems, a maker of cell phone earpieces and headsets.

    They’ve gained worldwide attention and have gone from a relative unknown to a poster child for viral campaigns.

    Response has been mixed. Some are saying its brilliant and you can’t argue with it’s success. Others say it’s the Internet at its worst—it preys upon our collective fears in order to sell a product.

    Even the Gawker Media Gossip Blog had this to say:

    It would be satisfying to see this uncovered as history’s worst viral campaign.

    Whether the makers of these videos realized it or not, by ‘proving’ an urban legend, these videos were Made to Stick.

    What do you think, is this campaign responsible or not?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    Keep it simple, smarty.

    Tuesday, June 10th, 2008

    Last week, I spoke at the Northwest Career Colleges Federation Annual Convention about Responsible Marketing. It was the third time I’d spoken to the group, and quite frankly I was surprised I was invited back. You see, I’ve prattled on about how poor advertising is in the education category.

    So often, education marketing falls into one of the categories below:

  • Amateurish, busy campaigns that are so bad, they are almost painful to watch.
  • Slightly better campaigns that feel like they are part of a direct response marketing template (because they often are). You know, these are the ads with the CSR’s with headsets saying, “call now!”
  • Advertising that tries too hard to be be ‘authentic’ and connect with college-age students. Kinda pathetic, like the 40-something white guy in the office talking about ’street cred.’
  • Some unholy amalgamation of the above.
  • Because of this, I always enjoy finding something good in the education category, in any medium.

    I discovered the following ads today from UNICID, Universidad Cidade De S. Paulo (roughly, The City University of São Paulo). I wish I found them sooner.

    The Headline:

    Competition starts earlier than ever.
    Stand-out with a post-graduate degree from UNICID.

    Click on any of the following ads to view a larger version.

    So often, advertising tries to cram so much in so little space. And so little is actually read.

    But these ads are simple, creative and confident.

    One glance and you get it. The concepts are strong so the copy reinforces more than it explains.

    By keeping it simple, UNICID zigged when this category typically zags. Bully to them for having the nerve to say less.

    And by keeping is simple, it makes UNICID look pretty smart, indeed.

    If you’ve seen good marketing in the education category, I’d love to see it.

    Comment below to share.

    . . .


    Inspiration for this post came from Ads of the World.

    Advertising Agency: FabraQuinteiro Comunicações, São Paulo, Brazil
    Creative Directors: Paschoal Fabra Neto, Marcelo Aragão
    Art Director: Bruno Cirello
    Copywriter: Ricardo Frezza
    Photographer: Marcelo Ribeiro
    Image Retouch: Fernando Vido, Burti HD
    Published: November 2007

    I’ve got some Cheetos. Let’s go vandalize something!

    Thursday, May 29th, 2008

    Are you ready to join the Orange Underground? You know, a place where you can cause a little mischief (RAoC – Random Acts of Cheetos) then upload your videos to YouTube and become rich (in Cheetos) and famous (on Comedy Central)?

    Here are a few of the professionally produced ads from the Orange Underground campaign:

    Okay, so they are humorous, sort of. And taken in and of themselves, pretty harmless.

    But Cheetos and ad agency Goodby, Silverstein & Partners of San Francisco weren’t interested in pretty harmless.

    Nope.

    It’s all about going viral these days, folks.

    It’s about building community.

    Heck, create a movement if you can.

    At the end of each ad, you are invited to “Join Now” by visiting OrangeUnderground.com. When you do, you are greeted by the twenty-something below who tells you what it’s all about.

    This “underground” is trying so hard and feels so phony, it’s like a bad SNL skit that won’t end. And I don’t mean so bad it’s good.

    So, what’s the deal with Random Acts of Cheetos, anyway?

    Bob Garfield describes it in his Ad Age article, Cheetos Ads That Promote ‘Random Acts’ Are Irresponsible:

    . . .there is another word for Random Acts of Cheetos: vandalism. The Cheetos Underground explicitly incites its shadowy network of crap eaters not only to perpetrate mischief but to document their petty crimes on video for the Cheetos website.

    Encouraging vandalism can hardly be considered socially responsible. But luckily for homeowners, teachers, bosses and innocent bystanders, this campaign wasn’t strategic or execution responsible and few have been molested with the orange snack.

    The underground campaign failed to recognize that this demographic seeks authenticity (an underground better look like an underground, not a Cheetos-branded one).

    And why would you have an animated spokes-tiger for a campaign like this? Remove him from the ads and they become instantly darker and more disturbing.

    I don’t get it, but is it working? I don’t know, but consider these facts:

    The blog is a ghost town (11 total posts, 26 total comments). There are only 135 user-generated videos on YouTube. And the total YouTube downloads over the last three months for all three videos above is a paltry 277,800 (70% are for the laundry commercial alone).

    Compare those view counts to some of the other viral videos discussed here over the last few months:

  • Viva Chihuahuas from Disney (485,000 in four weeks)
  • Charity Water (656,682 in eight weeks)
  • D2 Man from TopFlite (1,040,707 in eight weeks)
  • Verisign’s Cart Whisperer (1,199,346 in nine weeks)
  • Awareness Test for Transport of London (3,560,865 in eight weeks)
  • So, what’s the bigger crime?

    Trying to incite vandalism or the execution of the campaign itself?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    A burrito the size of a baby! No? Then show me your tortilla machine.

    Monday, May 12th, 2008

    One of the best places for Mexican food in Seattle is Gorditos, on 85th in Greenwood. Their burritos are ridiculously huge, modestly priced and delicious. When I say huge, I mean a regular is big enough for two—a large would serve a small family.

    Here’s a photo and caption from a 2006 restaurant review in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer:

    The $7.50 Gorditos Burrito Grande, billed as the burrito as big as a baby, is almost as big as this 11-week-old. You get a choice of meat in this double-tortilla-wrapped monstrosity.
    Photo credit: Joshua Trujillo/Seattle Post-Intelligencer

    Need I say more?

    Before I lived in a “built-green” urban village in the suburbs, I lived three blocks from Gorditos and it was my favorite place to eat. I was there enough, the owner usually knew I’d get a “regular-size half chicken, half steak, fajita style, wet burrito with a glass of horchata” without me having to open my mouth. That’s not to say the conversation wasn’t pleasant—she just remembered my order.

    The sheer size of the burritos gets people in. The taste keeps ‘em coming back.

    Unfortunately, there’s nothing quite like Gorditos anywhere near my work or home, but there is a Mexican restaurant near my office that does a decent business.

    Toreros is part of local chain that’s known for great service and authentic food. Their bar does well, their plates are big and the service is friendly, “gracias, amigo!”

    Although Toreros can’t match Gorditos’ shock and awe, their tortilla machine gets people talking too.

    They fire that baby up and make fresh tortillas right there during regular business hours. You walk in the door and “boom,” that fresh tortilla smell hits you. Kids and grownups gather around the machine and get free hot samples, a la Krispy Kreme.

    My kids will watch as long as you let them, and they love the fresh tortillas.

    Two questions:

    1. Have you experienced a remarkable brand lately?

    2. What’s stopping your company from doing something that’s remarkable—that will get people talking?

    Can you make the biggest widget? The world’s smallest?

    How about the world’s only only chartreuse widget?

    Is it possible for you take part of what you create and make it part of your customer experience?

    I’d love to hear about it.

    Comment below to weigh in.

    Marketing lessons from Dixie’s BBQ

    Monday, April 14th, 2008

    One of my favorite quotes of late is “Advertising is the tax you pay for being unremarkable,” credited to Robert Stephens, founder of Geek Squad at the Ad Age Idea Conference.

    I doubt Gene Porter from Dixie’s BBQ in Bellevue, WA has an advertising budget, nor does he need one.


    A few Outsource Marketing team members at Dixie’s. Founder Gene Porter is in the middle.

    Dixie’s is Seth Godin’s Purple Cow. It’s the company Andy Sernovitz challenges every organization to become in his book, Word of Mouth Marketing.

    But Porter didn’t need a marketing consultant to teach him how to create one of the most talked about lunch places around.

    How it started

    Originally an auto repair shop, rumor has it Porter started doing New Orleans style BBQ for the men and women building the 520 bridge. He realized he was on to something and quit fixing cars and started doing BBQ full-time. My CPA remembers it well. He showed up with his Honda for service and discovered he could buy a great BBQ sandwich, but he couldn’t get his car fixed.

    The old shop is still the main location for Dixie’s, and the line begins to form at about 11:15. The wait can be long, but it’s usually pretty entertaining. Porter is a charismatic man, to say the least. He can be the sweetest guy you’ve ever met, or can scare the hell out of you. He poses for pictures with patrons and has a, dare I say, charming side. He’ll also pull you out of line and force you to put a pin on one of the many maps indicating where you are from. Cut in line, even if you are meeting a friend, and he’ll throw you out. Park your car wrong in Dixie’s tiny lot, he’ll cuss you out, take your keys, and move it himself.

    People come from all over to \"Meet the Man.\"
    People come from all over to experience Dixie’s.

    And I mean ALL over.
    And I mean ALL over.

    People in line all buzz about the place, but most are nervously trying to determine their order before it’s their turn in line. The Soup Nazi has absolutely nothing on the staff at Dixie’s. Bumble through your order and you’ll be ripped a new one. They’ve softened up a bit, but regulars know to get their order straight before their turn.

    Have you met “The Man?”

    It’s the question Dixie’s regulars ask the uninitiated before they tell them about Dixie’s. Given the force of Porter’s personality, you’d think he was the star of the show. He’s a supporting actor. “The Man” isn’t a person. It’s the unbelievably hot “Man Sauce” that Porter carries around in a crusty pot that looks like its been brewing on the stove for a decade. Only the Good Lord knows what he has in there.

    This is \"The Man.\"
    This is “The Man.”

    Porter will take the tip of toothpick or fork and get a tiny amount of the sauce, then apply it to your BBQ sandwich. “The Man” is so potent, so incredibly strong, that the tiniest amount is more than enough for people who love their food hot. A little too much, and grown men won’t be able to finish their sandwich. The heat comes on strong and keeps on coming. The only thing that seems to cool it off are the free peanuts dotted around the restaurant.

    You think you know hot?

    On one occasion, I saw a man challenge Porter on the heat of “The Man.” He was an out-of-towner that “knew BBQ” and “knew hot.” You could have heard a pin drop. Everyone knew a smackdown of epic proportions was coming. And come it did. Porter destroyed him verbally, gave him just a little extra of “The Man,” and then have him take a big bite. The poor S.O.B. picked the wrong person to challenge. His face turned beet red, his eyes watered, and he left with his friends in a big hurry, I assume to the E.R.

    Honestly, I think they should have everyone sign a waiver. Seriously.

    Built for word of mouth

    Dixie’s walls are covered with the aforementioned U.S. and World Maps. One fills up, they get a new one. They’ve had to retire maps when the concentration of the pins was so dense you couldn’t add another. They are also covered with pictures of people who have visited and taken pictures from their experience. Take a picture with Porter and he’ll remind you to bring a copy and hang it up. Two or three times.

    Photos, photos everywhere.

    He’s a natural marketer, and I’ve often wondered how much of his bluster is real or if he realizes he’s really in show business. I certainly don’t have the nerve to ask him myself.

    I do know this much: Dixie’s doesn’t have the pay a tax for being unremarkable.

    Do you know a remarkable company? A company that you just can’t not talk about? I’d love to hear about it.

    The New Coffee Wars: Who will prevail?

    Friday, April 11th, 2008

    I drink a grande decaf over ice with heavy cream every morning. Although I eliminated caffeine about three years ago, it’s still part of my morning ritual. I still feel off if I don’t get my fix.

    Considering over 52% of Americans over age 18 drink coffee everyday, is it any wonder McDonald’s, Dunkin’ Donuts and a slew of others want a piece of Starbucks‘ action?

    Dunkin’ Donuts’ has moved much of its marketing focus to coffee and has taken direct aim at Starbucks:

    Over the last few years, McDonald’s increased its coffee ad spend, and even offers Newman’s Own Organic Coffee in some locations:

    In Western Washington, McDonald’s is currently offering an online coupon good for one of their new espresso drinks at select McDonald’s locations. You can print the coupon at unsnobbycoffee.com.

    The site is simple, but gives you the opportunity to interact with the brand. You can play Hotshot Pinball or do a snobby coffee intervention. Fill in the blanks, then sending it to a friend. Not a bad word of mouth tool.

    Snobby coffee intervention. Fill in the form and send to a friend.

    This competition couldn’t be coming at a tougher time for Starbucks. It’s stock is at $17.55 a share today (it’s down from $32 a year ago). Howard Schultz recently returned to the helm and has made a number of positive changes:

  • A return to the core business by eliminating a number of food products – “It smells like coffee again!” my barista told me yesterday
  • New “Pike Place Roast” coffee is fresh-ground and fresh-brewed every 30 minutes (I tried it yesterday – it’s honestly the best cup of coffee I’ve ever had at an SBUX)
  • New espresso machines that are lower so the baristas can see the customer
  • Free refills when you use your Starbuck’s card
  • The Starbucks refresh also included a new customer forum called My Starbucks Idea. It’s not a social networking site, but as a tool for creating conversation with customers, it’s quite good. In Starbucks adopts IdeaStorm concept, Shel Holtz did a nice job comparing it to Dell’s Ideastorm.

    Who will prevail?

    Dunkin’ Donuts is obviously known for their dunkers and their drip coffee. They may take some of Starbucks customers – especially those that care less about coffee or the coffee experience than they do convenience.

    McDonald’s has immense distribution, so they’ll always be a threat. McDonald’s employees will probably never be trained baristas. But if their coffee tastes good enough, some will buy it there instead of walking across the parking lot to a “real coffee shop.”

    My bet is on Starbucks. At a time when customers are seeking authenticity, they are returning to the recipe that helped them succeed. Their focus on service as well as improving and increasing the dialog they are having with their customers is the responsible thing to do, and I believe they will be rewarded for it.

    So, where do you grab your coffee, and why?