Archive for the ‘digital marketing’ Category

Facebook’s ad feedback function fail

Monday, September 21st, 2009

You know the ads on the right hand column of your Facebook feeds page?

Here’s a view I’ve received a lot lately:

mafia wars ads

Yeah. I know. You’ve seen these ads enough already.

Not sure why I’d receive ‘em…I’m not a gamer and there’s nothing in my profile that would lead you to believe I’d be interested in this.  In fact, I really don’t like seeing a gun or a crime scene every time I log on to Facebook.

So I’ve nuked these ads whenever I’ve seen them, using Facebook’s advertising feedback feature:

facebook ad feedback

Now that’s what advertisers and users are looking for: Users can receive tailored ads, and advertisers can build a feedback loop for their creative.

Well, at least in concept.

You see, I decided to delete all the “Mafia Wars” ads that popped up, and they simply kept appearing—sometimes two to three of them at once. It didn’t seem to matter which reason I gave, they still littered my screen.

Look, I like a good mob movie as much as the next guy—but what if I really found these offensive? I’d be pissed.

This practice isn’t just anti-user, it’s anti-advertiser.

Somebody has said every way they can that they don’t want to see your ad—but Facebook is still serving them up?

Sure, the feedback widget says “Over time, this information helps us deliver more relevant ads to our users” but if you are given the option to remove an ad because it’s offensive, misleading or anything else on the list, shouldn’t your wishes be granted there and then? Are there any advertisers out there that really want to offend people over and over?

I started deleting the “Mafia Wars” ads weeks ago. And while they don’t pop up nearly as much, I’m still receiving them.

It’s nice Facebook is asking for feedback, especially since it appears they are using the information provided to improve the user experience…somewhat.

But they aren’t asking people to passively answer a poll regarding the color of their wallpaper. They are asking people if they find an ad offensive or misleading. If the user says “yes, this offends me,” the ad needs to disappear from their user experience—forever.

What do you think?

Subscribe to this feed.

How Ford made me reconsider my auto buying habits

Wednesday, May 27th, 2009

I’ve owned dozens of cars, and like a lot of people, most have been Japanese or German. So when I turned in my leased Honda and started the hunt for a new hybrid, I drove the Toyota Prius, Camry and Highlander Hybrids, the new Honda Insight and a Lexus RX 400h.

  • The Prius felt underpowered
  • The Camry was nice, but felt too much like the Accord I’d just turned in
  • The Insight was loud and somewhat disappointing
  • And the Highlander Hybrid was so close in price to the Lexus, I chose the latter of the two

But the events of the last week have me second-guessing myself, and I have Ford’s social media marketing team (and a great product) to blame for it.

Let me explain.

A few weeks ago, Ford contacted me “looking for fresh perspectives and feedback, something a little more engaging and authentic” from “non-traditional approach for bloggers and other content creators” and asked if I’d be interested in test driving the new Fusion Hybrid for a few days.

I agreed, and last Thursday, they delivered a shiny new one to my office, with the Michigan “Manufacturer” plate and all.

Here are few pictures I snapped with my iPhone:

I drove the car to work, to the beach, to Costco, to a Mariners game. Basically everywhere.

The fit and finish were good and the ride was really quiet. In fact, it put my both my high-energy kids to sleep on the ride back from their grandma’s house. Sounds like a cliche, but it’s true.

I got a lot of comments from neighbors “That’s really a nice car,” co-workers “I’d buy that” and was even given a special parking spot by a parking lot attendant after he said “Is that the new Fusion Hybrid—cool!”

What I liked most was the fact I nearly forgot it was a hybrid. The transfer from electric to gas is less obvious than it is with my Lexus, a fact that the press hasn’t missed, with USA Today calling it the best gas-electric hybrid yet.

Oh, and while I didn’t get the 81.5 miles per gallon achieved in a recent hypermiling stunt, I did get a respectable 39.5 MPG in a mid-size car.

All-in-all, an eye-opening experience.

Ford’s social media team is firing on all cylinders

You might have heard the buzz about the Fiesta Movement, Ford’s social campaign that put 100 “agents” (selected from over 4,000 applicants) behind the wheel of a 2011 Ford Fiesta for six months and how they’re sharing the results of their “missions” on Facebook, Twitter, Flickr and YouTube.

Ford is winning on the social web due to the aggressive approach that Scott Monty and Ford’s social media team have been taking to engage customers and build authentic conversations around their products and brands.

A return to the past?

Their bet is that if people actually drive a Ford, they might buy one. In fact, Alan Mullaly, CEO of Ford, is interested in resurrecting “Have you driven a Ford lately?” campaign from the mid 1980’s.

Here’s an ad from that campaign that aired in 1984, the year I graduated from high school.

So, why didn’t I consider Ford?

Old attitudes and habits die hard.

Recent research from Nielsen puts Ford’s brand advocacy quotient below companies such as Kia, Pontiac and Chrysler.

While Ford’s branding and social media campaigns are good, I’ve become brand loyal to other manufacturers and it will take a lot to break that hold.

Ford’s dealers still publish absurdly noisy ads with prices the average buyer will seldom get (loyalty discounts, military discounts, first-time buyer discounts, etc)— and you’ll always have to haggle with the salesperson and expect them to bring in the manager when they can’t close the sale.

Still, that happens with most dealers and Ford’s product is good and worth a look.

People like me have been saying “Once American manufacturers catch up with Japanese and Germans, I’ll start buying American cars again.”

Well folks, has that time come? Ford’s product quality and the way they’re communicating with customers has me reconsidering their offerings.

Would you consider a Ford?

Comment below to weigh in.

Subscribe to this feed.

Hyperconnected teens: The staggering statistics

Thursday, February 26th, 2009

13-year-old Megan Pozgar, 2007 LG Texting Champion, won $25,000 for the word "supercalifragilisticexpialidocious"

Much has been said about how connected Gen Y is. But I was shocked when I learned that teens with a cell phone average 2,272 text messages per month.

That’s works out to over 73 messages per day, or 4.5 per hour assuming eight hours of sleep. This is compared to an average of 203 calls per month, or a mere 6.5 calls per day.

Recent research has shown the average teen in the UK spends 31 hours online. That’s nine hours shy of a full-time job, folks.

Hyperconnected teens are always on and they are always talking—about everything. That includes the good, the bad and the ugly about your company and its products and services.

What’s more, Gen Y is huge. At about 76 million people, it’s about as big as the Baby Boomer generation.

Let’s just say it would be wise to stay on their good side.

This is the largest, most connected generation ever. It changes the game for everyone in marketing: To be responsible, marketing via web, social media and mobile devices simply can’t be considered an optional add-on anymore.

So, what do you think about all of this?

Subscribe to this feed.

. . .

Image: From Shaping Youth, 13-year-old Megan Pozgar, 2007 LG Texting Champion, won $25,000 for the word “supercalifragilisticexpialidocious.”

Marketing personalization tips and pitfalls

Wednesday, September 24th, 2008

Personalization has been the marketer’s holy grail for a long time.

From 1998-2002 I instructed the Integrated Marketing Communications course at the University of Washington. The first few years, I used The One-to-One Future by Don Peppers and Martha Rogers as one of my textbooks.

Of course, one of the key messages of the book centered on making messaging more personalized. “Dear Patrick” is way better than “Dear Customer,” after all.

Permission Marketing was another one of my texts. It raised the bar and said that every message you send must be “anticipated, personal and relevant.”

Now, technology has made it easy to personalize email marketing messages, web landing pages, direct mail, and more. Promotional items have been personalized for years, but the options today are mind-boggling.

Viral online games that you can personalize by uploading your own photos are now mainstream.

Here’s a video about my run for the Presidency that shows just how far you can go with personalization:

Patrick Byers for President - Click to view the video.

Most consumers prefer personalized messages, and personalization increases open rates, response rates and just about every metric that matters to marketers.

Should you start personalizing all your marketing messages?

Well, yes and no.

Personalization often backfires. My wife’s name is Arden, and I can’t tell you how many pieces of mail she gets calling her “Mr. Arden Byers.”

Privacy is a concern. Get too personal and consumers get nervous. You’d surely received the mortgage refinance letters that know exactly what you owe? “They know too much about me – that’s creepy,” is a common response. Personally, I get angry.

Personalized isn’t necessarily personal. Simply inserting someone’s first name after the word “Dear” may not be enough.

Today, Freddy Nager wrote an interesting post regarding the way rock bands, and in the case, Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails connects with his fans.

His comments regarding personalization got my juices flowing and are the inspiration for this post.

No, the letter doesn’t address me by name, but fans are savvy enough to know that no rock star can personally address millions of fans, so Reznor simply avoids that pretense.

(Junk mailers take note: just because you use my first name in the salutation doesn’t make me think it’s personal.)

At the same time, he writes in first person, addresses the reader as “you,” and speaks to them in a casual, uncensored way.

Compare that to the emails many of us get from corporations: “Dear Freddy, We at Humongoloid Bank Inc. want to thank our customers for another record year…”

Chew on that for a minute, then tell me, while personalization matters now, how long do you think it will be before consumers get “personalization fatigue?”

Put another way, how long before marketing personalization becomes so prevalent it becomes irrelevant?

Comment below to share your thoughts.

Subscribe to this feed.

Are you looking for love in all the wrong places?

Monday, September 22nd, 2008

I wish people didn’t call it “new media” anymore.

It’s just media.

But unlike television, radio and print, this media is created by you, me, your co-workers—maybe even your mom.

It’s a conversation that brings you closer to the customer than ever before at a time when recent research has shown that 86% of consumers don’t believe brands, but 78% of consumers believe what their peers say about brands.

But check out this comparison of average media usage versus average media spend from Chris Schaumann’s excellent Digital Branding presentation.

Click to view Chris Schaumann's Digital Branding presentation

The disconnect is immediately evident: If you aren’t marketing online, you’re looking for love in all the wrong places.

So, what about the customers you already have?

The Break Up is an award-winning viral video from Microsoft that shows the painful disconnect between what today’s consumer wants, and how advertisers are (or aren’t) responding:

So, what are you doing to engage your customer and prospects?

Comment below to share.

Subscribe to this feed.

. . .

Inspiration for this post came, albeit circuitously, from the following people: Justin Marshall > Ryan Turner > Geert Desager > Chris Schaumann

Bite-sized Friday: Chickens to China

Friday, July 11th, 2008


Savage Chickens, by Doug Savage

  • Bennett Gordon from the always good Utne Reader shared the following interview with Lucas Conley, author of Obsessive Branding Disorder. Includes audio, video and a link to an excerpt from the book.
  • Looking for social media case studies? Here are 27 of ‘em from Now is Gone, by Geoff Livingston.
  • In Indecent exposures: Companies don’t care who carries their ads, Randy Siegal discusses how online ads for some of the nation’s most respected companies are being showcased next to controversial content.
  • “After the Olympic Games, the fight for human rights must go on.” Regardless of where you stand on China’s human rights record and the Olympics, these images from Amnesty International are chilling.
  • Thoughts regarding anything shared today?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    Responsible Marketing on socialmedia.alltop.com

    Tuesday, June 24th, 2008

    Featured in Alltop

    Alltop is the excellent blog aggregation site that offers “aggregation without aggravation” because it lists just the best of the best blogs.

    I was honored to be included in the marketing.alltop category in May and gave you Responsible Marketers the opportunity to weigh in on which badge I should use.

    So, imagine my surprise when I learned that the Responsible Marketing Blog has been added to socialmedia.alltop category.

    This list includes the thinking of some of the best minds in social media, and I’m humbled to be included.

    Thanks to you for making The Responsible Marketing Blog part of your day, and to Alltop for including it on their list.

    Using social media to create social good

    Monday, June 23rd, 2008

    By popular demand, here’s my deck from PodCamp Seattle:

    SlideShare

    As you probably noticed, I’m not a big fan of slides full of bullets—it’s mostly images.

    View all the websites mentioned in the deck, as well as all the sites recommended by Twitter friends here:
    http://del.icio.us/patrickbyers/socialgood

    I’ve also bookmarked all of the Twitter contributors in case you’d like to follow them:
    http://del.icio.us/patrickbyers/twittergood

    Last, special thanks to Eric Weaver from Edelman Digital who coordinated PodCamp, and to Guy Kawasaki and Chris Brogan, for using reaching out to their network to help me find great examples for this presentation.

    So, who’s doing a great job in the social good space?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    Are you amped for PodCamp? Join me in Seattle on June 21st

    Wednesday, May 28th, 2008

    Responsible marketers know that social media is changing the business landscape and has become an integral part of the marketing mix.

    If you don’t know social media because you just haven’t had the time to figure it out, now you can get a good primer in less than one day—for free.

    PodCamp is coming to Seattle.

    Conference focus areas

  • Intro/101 Discussions – A quick primer
  • Marketing/PR/Advertising Discussions – The tools you should know about
  • Technology Discussions – The technical nuts and bolts
  • Social Good Discussions – Using social tools to connect and give back
  • Where, when and registration

    PodCamp Seattle
    Saturday, June 21, 2008
    9:00 a.m. – 3:30 p.m.
    University of Washington Communications Building

    Register

    My topic

    Using Social Media to Create Social Good
    1:30 p.m. // Room 304

    This looks to be a feature-packed event.

    Will I see you there?

    . . .

    Special thanks to Eric Weaver over at Edelman Digital for organizing this. It’s challenging, thankless work!

    Beware of “no brainer” marketing tactics

    Tuesday, May 20th, 2008

    We all know it now: Digital marketing kicks butt.

    Organizations big and small should be investing in paid search, SEO and email marketing. In some categories the ROI makes putting most (if not all) of your marketing budget into digital marketing a no-brainer.

    Or is it?

    Care to guess how many people have never sent an email in the U.S.?

    Nope. That’s way too low.

    According to a recent study by Park Associates, 20% of the U.S. population has never sent an email.

    “No brainer” ideas often end up making people wonder if we indeed have no brains.

    Consider your target: Where they go for their information. How they make their buying decisions. What turns them on.

    Consider the promotional cost effectiveness of each marketing discipline relative to the stages of buyer readiness. To be responsible, your marketing must be media and discipline neutral.

    And whatever you do, don’t put all your marketing eggs in a digital basket.

    Have you ever been told about a “no brainer” marketing idea? How did it turn out?

    Comment below to share your thoughts.

    Subscribe to this feed.

    . . .

    The graphic is our prettied up version of a graph in Philip Kotler’s Marketing Management.