Posts Tagged ‘Seth Godin’

Deception is not Responsible Marketing

Wednesday, June 11th, 2008

Liberty Names of America regularly sends us expiration notices for our domain name renewals. Problem is, they aren’t our domain registrar. Their notices are formatted like invoices in a ploy to get us to transfer our domains to them.

Click on the image below to take a closer look:

+Click to enlarge

Of course, when you give Liberty your credit card number and sign the front page you’ve approved the transfer of your domain.

Nice.

Is Liberty breaking the law?

I don’t think so.

There is a sentence that says “By moving your domain name to Liberty Names of America you can take advantage of the savings we have to offer,” and at the bottom, it does say “…transfer and renew” twice.

But review the notice and tell me, are they aren’t asking for your business or trying to trick you into doing business with them?


Deceptive marketing takes many forms

This nonsense has been going on for years, of course. Mortgage companies implying you can reduce your payment, when they aren’t your mortgage company; checks that, upon deposit, transfer your long distance phone service; loss leader prices with absurd strings attached; direct mail designed to look like official government business and and the like all fall into this category.

Even the the Better Business Bureau has gotten into the act. We regularly receive notifications of a “BBB inquiry” requiring our immediate attention. When we’ve responded, we learn it’s actually a solicitation for our company to join the Better Business Bureau. They quit calling me. But last week they called one of my partners.

This isn’t an isolated case. It’s the way the BBB does business. Seth Godin received a call like this, and felt the same way.

Unbelievable.

These tactics often work due to the fact that as consumers we’re all dealing with information overload, and we’re so busy we process little things like this quickly, often without reading every word.

I remember when I was in high school and college, I evaluated scams like these for my parents, who may very well have fallen for this tomfoolery.

It infuriated me then and it infuriates me now.

Are duped customers happy customers? Do they stick around? Do they refer others?

I think not.

Marketing likes this makes Responsible Marketers look bad, and for this reason, deceptive marketers, you belong in the Responsible Marketing Hall of Shame.

Where have you seen deceptive marketing?

Comment below to weigh in.

Pump up the volume to improve marketing? Maybe not.

Tuesday, June 3rd, 2008

Gilmore Group

I’ve spoken about the effects of information overload for over a decade, and have written a post or two on the subject as well.

Because info glut makes it so difficult to break through, as marketers we’ll try just about anything:

  • We’ll make our ads bigger. While big ads are usually better than small ads, they cost more.
  • We pump up the volume on our radio and television ads. This may get your listener’s attention, but it isn’t message responsible and really doesn’t respect your audience, either.
  • We find new ways to interrupt. Whether it’s a breakthrough ad, a telemarketer’s call at dinner, a lumpy mailer, or a humongous billboard like the one being constructed in Times Square, it’s still an interruption.
  • We do it more often. If seven times won’t get you to pay attention, maybe seventy will?
  • In Permission Marketing, Seth Godin sums up the irony of advertising well:

    The more they spend, the less it works.
    The less it works, the more they spend.

    The truth hurts, doesn’t it?

    We’re fans of permission here, and use it whenever it makes sense.

    But we’re always looking for better ways to responsibly get attention.

    Usually that means pumping up the creativity, not the volume.

    How do you break through responsibly?

    Comment below to weigh in.

    Marketing lessons from Dixie’s BBQ

    Monday, April 14th, 2008

    One of my favorite quotes of late is “Advertising is the tax you pay for being unremarkable,” credited to Robert Stephens, founder of Geek Squad at the Ad Age Idea Conference.

    I doubt Gene Porter from Dixie’s BBQ in Bellevue, WA has an advertising budget, nor does he need one.


    A few Outsource Marketing team members at Dixie’s. Founder Gene Porter is in the middle.

    Dixie’s is Seth Godin’s Purple Cow. It’s the company Andy Sernovitz challenges every organization to become in his book, Word of Mouth Marketing.

    But Porter didn’t need a marketing consultant to teach him how to create one of the most talked about lunch places around.

    How it started

    Originally an auto repair shop, rumor has it Porter started doing New Orleans style BBQ for the men and women building the 520 bridge. He realized he was on to something and quit fixing cars and started doing BBQ full-time. My CPA remembers it well. He showed up with his Honda for service and discovered he could buy a great BBQ sandwich, but he couldn’t get his car fixed.

    The old shop is still the main location for Dixie’s, and the line begins to form at about 11:15. The wait can be long, but it’s usually pretty entertaining. Porter is a charismatic man, to say the least. He can be the sweetest guy you’ve ever met, or can scare the hell out of you. He poses for pictures with patrons and has a, dare I say, charming side. He’ll also pull you out of line and force you to put a pin on one of the many maps indicating where you are from. Cut in line, even if you are meeting a friend, and he’ll throw you out. Park your car wrong in Dixie’s tiny lot, he’ll cuss you out, take your keys, and move it himself.

    People come from all over to \"Meet the Man.\"
    People come from all over to experience Dixie’s.

    And I mean ALL over.
    And I mean ALL over.

    People in line all buzz about the place, but most are nervously trying to determine their order before it’s their turn in line. The Soup Nazi has absolutely nothing on the staff at Dixie’s. Bumble through your order and you’ll be ripped a new one. They’ve softened up a bit, but regulars know to get their order straight before their turn.

    Have you met “The Man?”

    It’s the question Dixie’s regulars ask the uninitiated before they tell them about Dixie’s. Given the force of Porter’s personality, you’d think he was the star of the show. He’s a supporting actor. “The Man” isn’t a person. It’s the unbelievably hot “Man Sauce” that Porter carries around in a crusty pot that looks like its been brewing on the stove for a decade. Only the Good Lord knows what he has in there.

    This is \"The Man.\"
    This is “The Man.”

    Porter will take the tip of toothpick or fork and get a tiny amount of the sauce, then apply it to your BBQ sandwich. “The Man” is so potent, so incredibly strong, that the tiniest amount is more than enough for people who love their food hot. A little too much, and grown men won’t be able to finish their sandwich. The heat comes on strong and keeps on coming. The only thing that seems to cool it off are the free peanuts dotted around the restaurant.

    You think you know hot?

    On one occasion, I saw a man challenge Porter on the heat of “The Man.” He was an out-of-towner that “knew BBQ” and “knew hot.” You could have heard a pin drop. Everyone knew a smackdown of epic proportions was coming. And come it did. Porter destroyed him verbally, gave him just a little extra of “The Man,” and then have him take a big bite. The poor S.O.B. picked the wrong person to challenge. His face turned beet red, his eyes watered, and he left with his friends in a big hurry, I assume to the E.R.

    Honestly, I think they should have everyone sign a waiver. Seriously.

    Built for word of mouth

    Dixie’s walls are covered with the aforementioned U.S. and World Maps. One fills up, they get a new one. They’ve had to retire maps when the concentration of the pins was so dense you couldn’t add another. They are also covered with pictures of people who have visited and taken pictures from their experience. Take a picture with Porter and he’ll remind you to bring a copy and hang it up. Two or three times.

    Photos, photos everywhere.

    He’s a natural marketer, and I’ve often wondered how much of his bluster is real or if he realizes he’s really in show business. I certainly don’t have the nerve to ask him myself.

    I do know this much: Dixie’s doesn’t have the pay a tax for being unremarkable.

    Do you know a remarkable company? A company that you just can’t not talk about? I’d love to hear about it.

    Seth Godin on curiousity (and creativity)

    Monday, March 3rd, 2008

    Boring marketing is irresponsible. Responsible Marketing puts a premium on creativity. And creativity only happens when you are able to stay curious.

    Here’s what Seth Godin has to say about it:

    How long has it been since you’ve allowed yourself to be curious?

    Afraid of doing something really different with your marketing? Don’t be:

    The safest thing to do is risky.
    And the riskiest thing you can do is play it safe.

    Take a break from ordinary today. Allow yourself to be curious.

    Start by asking yourself, where have you seen creativity lately, real creativity? The kind that makes you want to run out and tell someone about it?

    Tell me about it. Tell us about it.

    Weigh in by commenting below, especially if you’ve never commented on a blog before!